When DEI Meets Reality: Sourcing Impossible Reqs

How can you increase minority representation when minorities are scarcely present in your industry?

SourceCon Community, 

Hey.
Hi.
Hello.
Whassuupppp???!!!

Do people still say that? I mean, I know they tried to bring it back once before. But I don’t think it stuck. Well, one thing I know people are still talking about is DEI initiatives.  It was a hot topic at ERE last week in Austin, TX and among the chatter in their roundtables. Quick aside, the ERE conference was very well done. Check out some of my favorite quotes from the conference…

  • "Quality of hire isn't pornography where you know it when you see it." Mary Faulkner

  • "The more data you share, the more data they want." Melissa Thompson

  • "Empathy - The first step to a good candidate experience" Craig Fisher

  • "Slides don't kill people. Bullets (bullet points on a slide) kill people." Jason Roberts

  • "HR is the place you go when you can't get a government job. When I heard that I wanted to punch him." Jim Durbin

  • "AI is a drunk looking for his housekeys under a streetlamp." Jim Durbin

If you ever have an HR itch to scratch, ERE is the place to be, but I digress. I was talking about DEI.

A diverse group of squirrels…

People were discussing its importance and how recent developments have endangered its progress. DEI received a lot of support but I could not help but wonder if people were more concerned about being politically correct and not seeing things more objectively. I give you an example of what I mean. I remember this article from a few years back. I quote…

Cesar Conde, the new chairman of NBCUniversal News Group, outlined a workforce goal of 50% diversity on Tuesday, telling employees that as “a news organization we have a unique responsibility to reflect the country and all of the communities we serve.”

“The NBCUniversal News Group is not going to wait for change to happen and just react to it.  We’re going to lead,” he said in a video to employees on Tuesday. “As a news organization, we have a unique responsibility to look like and reflect all of the people of the country we serve.”

He said that the goal is for 50% of the news organization employees to be women and 50% of their total workforce be people of color, with plans to boost recruitment and education programs and to invest in more documentaries and investigative content focusing on communities of color. The 50% goal is long term, with no exact date set to reach it, but he said that progress would be reported publicly every year.

While I can appreciate the intent behind his goals, is it realistic? For that matter, are companies with similar goals likely to succeed. I think not, solely based on talent analytics. Let me give you a few examples.

Consider the labor force statistics from the current population survey, which is data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. It sums up the percentage of minorities in various industries.

Bureau of Labor Statistics

Based on the data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), some of the industries with the lowest minority representation, showing significant discrepancies in diversity:

  1. Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers: 96.2% White, 1.4% Black, 0.8% Asian, 6.4% Hispanic.

  2. Cost Estimators: 96.2% White, 0.3% Black, 1.9% Asian, 7.6% Hispanic.

  3. Property Appraisers and Assessors: 94.7% White, 0.6% Black, 4.1% Asian, 11.9% Hispanic.

  4. Surveying and Mapping Technicians: 94.8% White, 2.3% Black, 1.5% Asian, 8.7% Hispanic.

  5. Insurance Sales Agents: 88.1% White, 5.8% Black, 2.7% Asian, 11.0% Hispanic.

  6. Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents: 86.2% White, 5.9% Black, 4.7% Asian, 11.8% Hispanic.

  7. Financial Managers: 80.3% White, 8.4% Black, 9.3% Asian, 9.3% Hispanic.

Given this situation, is it realistic for companies in these industries to significantly boost the proportion of Asian, Latino, or African-American representation within their workforce, when BLS data indicates that these groups are underrepresented?

Now am I suggesting that diversity sourcing and recruitment is a waste of time? Certainly not! There is plenty of data supporting the assertion that company diversity leads to better profits. However, I do think a healthy dose of data is necessary for managing the expectations of hiring managers with unrealistic demands. As I meditate on it now, I think DEI initiatives are a strong argument on why Sourcers need to be trusted advisors and not only champions at finding purple squirrels.  

But hey, maybe I have it all wrong? What do you think? Hit reply and share your thoughts. I want to hear from you.

Sincerely,

Jim Stroud
Your SourceCon Editor

P.S. If you would like a shout-out in an upcoming episode of “The Source!,” tag us on social media (@SourceCon) with the hashtag #SourceConShoutOut and I will do what I can. 

;-) 

Fresh Content

The Source - Episode 23

My Interview with AI

A viral social media post leads Jim Stroud to investigate an AI and its recruiting prowess. Does it live up to all the hype? Well, the jury is out, but the evidence is compelling. See for yourself. 

The Source - Episode 22

Ryan Fish Did the Impossible

Ryan Fish was given, what some would call, an impossible assignment. Do in 5 weeks what other recruiters could not accomplish in a year. The end result? Victory. Learn how Ryan Fish completed an "impossible" mission and what he would do differently if given the same assignment today.

Upcoming Conferences

SourceCon

San Diego | Digital

October 22-23, 2024

Learn from and connect with sourcing leaders and professionals. This isn't your typical conference — it's an immersive experience that goes beyond the surface, delving deep into the innovative strategies and cutting-edge technologies that are reshaping the sourcing landscape. (SourceCon)

ERE Recruiting Conference

Anaheim | Digital

November 12-14, 2024

The ERE Recruiting Conference is the premier independent practitioner-led recruiting event that provides actionable insights for TA pros, by TA pros. Join fellow colleagues to discover practical ideas, best practices, and case study solutions from leaders who share your toughest recruiting challenges — and have experience overcoming them. (ERE Recruiting Conference)

Talent42

Seattle | Digital

June 3-4, 2024

The No. 1 tech recruiting conference will be returning in June to provide best practices in small-group settings from some of the best talent acquisition professionals in the world. From impactful presentations to candid roundtables to hands-on workshops, this is the conference you do not want to miss. (Talent42)

SourceCon Meme of the Week

How integrated is AI in your sourcing processes? Asking for a friend.

May the source be with you!

Jim Stroud
Your SourceCon Editor
[email protected]