Decoding the Myth of Being 'Overqualified

What it really means when recruiters say you are overqualified...

Sourcing Community,

Have you seen the chart Mike Wolford posted on his Linkedin? It depicts the job opening demand for recruiters and that it is about where it was in June 2021. He then asks the question if we are having a summer uptick in jobs or a summer burnout? Interesting.

For those who don’t know, I am also a co-host on the Boolean and Brews podcast and this chart was discussed in an upcoming episode. As we bantered about it, the term “overqualified” was a hot topic as well. So much so, I decided to go further with what I think it means in this newsletter because I know many of you are open to new opportunities. I also know several of you will hear it as an excuse why you were not hired. Oh, the irony.

Sure, on one hand it is a compliment that someone thinks you are too good to be working for them, but on the other hand you still have to eat and being overqualified is not putting food on the table.

In case the term “overqualified” has been an enigma wrapped up in a mystery for some of you, let me suggest what employers really mean when they throw that word around. And as recruiters, I would LOVE to know how true or false my allegations are.

Let the demystification begin… (Insert the sounds of monks chanting here)

  • You’re going to drop them as soon as a better job comes along and no employer wants to get somebody “broken in” only for him or her to leave in a short period of time and go through the process all over again. (If you are single and looking to get married, you may be able to identify with this one better than the previous example.)

  • With your experience, no doubt you would be an expensive hire and they are not trying to spend any money, especially on your paycheck. If it’s not your paycheck, then raises designed to get you back to the compensation you are accustomed to or even sick leave.

  • You’ve been there and done that and you’re going to get bored with the job as it is beneath your talents. Not only will that make it hard to motivate you, but also you might become something like an apathetic virus infecting the rest of the crew.

Dealing with these issues and fears will take a great deal of tact and care, but remember that you are the most qualified choice; you just have to convince them of that. I suggest you…

  • Tell them how much money your experience will save them and give examples where you improved profit margins and business processes.

  • Point out that you are looking for a “home” and not a “job” and that you believe in what they are doing so much that you are willing to take a cut.

  • Stress how much of a team player you are and how that as an “overqualified” worker you overwork to get the job done, something exemplified in your resume, references and letters of recommendation.

Like anything else it is a sales pitch. But at least by addressing the issues mentioned above, you can muster a good defense with a strong first striking offense.

Good luck out there!

Jim Stroud
Your SourceCon Editor 

P.S. Time is rapidly running out on the 2-article Sourcers Anonymous deal. Take advantage of it while you can.

Fresh Content

Sourcing Diversity by Researching Luminaries

If you source diversity candidates, without a doubt you are familiar with the Grace Hopper Celebration. If not, the Grace Hopper Celebration (GHC) is an annual event that celebrates women in computing and technology. Named after the pioneering computer scientist Grace Hopper, the event is organized by AnitaB.org in collaboration with the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM). The Grace Hopper Celebration is more than just a conference; it is a movement that seeks to change the face of technology by recognizing and amplifying the voices of women in the industry. When I read this, or rather reflect on it as I’ve known about this event for ages, I am wondering what other diverse groups I could target by focusing on other luminaries who happen to be people of color. Let’s try an experiment.

Ghost jobs!

A ghost job is a job posting for a position that is either non-existent or has already been filled. These job listings appear to be open and available, but the employer has no actual intention of hiring for the role at that time. They waste a recruiter's time and frustrate job seekers to no end. eGrabber claims to have a tool that can detect them. I investigate to see if its true. Tune in to find out for yourself.

Upcoming Conferences

SourceCon

San Diego | Digital

October 22-23, 2024

Learn from and connect with sourcing leaders and professionals. This isn't your typical conference — it's an immersive experience that goes beyond the surface, delving deep into the innovative strategies and cutting-edge technologies that are reshaping the sourcing landscape. (SourceCon)

ERE Recruiting Conference

Anaheim | Digital

November 12-14, 2024

The ERE Recruiting Conference is the premier independent practitioner-led recruiting event that provides actionable insights for TA pros, by TA pros. Join fellow colleagues to discover practical ideas, best practices, and case study solutions from leaders who share your toughest recruiting challenges — and have experience overcoming them. (ERE Recruiting Conference)

The Weekly Meme

Somewhere in the forest, auditions are being held for a very special performance of “The Nutcracker” ballet. Stay tuned…

May the source be with you!

Jim Stroud
Your SourceCon Editor
[email protected]